Connect with us

Law & Crime

Dismiss PDP’s petition on Edo Guber, INEC tells Tribunal as judgement reserved

Published

on

Judiciary logo

By Abdul-Ganiyy Akanbi

The Edo State Governorship Election Petition Tribunal has adjourned indefinitely judgement in the petition filed against the September 21, 2024 election of Governor Monday Okpebholo of the All Progressives Congress (APC) by the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) and its governorship candidate, Mr Asue Ighodalo.

The tribunal adjourned the verdict delivery in the disputed election on Monday in Abuja after taking arguments from the petitioners, comprising Ighodalo and PDP and the respondents which included; the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) Okpebholo and the APC.

At the adoption of final written addresses, Justice Wilfred Kpochi, who permitted the petitioners and the respondents some minutes to adumbrate on their arguments, told parties that the date for judgement delivery in the petition would be communicated to them when ready.

At Monday’s proceedings, a former Attorney-General of the Federation (AGF), Chief Kanu Agabi, SAN stood for the electoral body, while Onyechi Ikpeazu, SAN addressed the tribunal on behalf of Governor Okpebholo and Chief Emmanuel Ukala, SAN argued for the APC.

The INEC lawyer said that the petition cannot stand the test of time based on the grounds that the tribunal could not annul the September 21, 2024 governorship election because it was not one of the reliefs sought by the petitioners.

The senior lawyer also told the tribunal that it could not declare Ighodalo and PDP as winners of the election in the light of their own assertion that the election was invalid.

Speaking on the claim of non-compliance pleaded by the petitioners, Agabi said it was weak as it was not accompanied by the appropriate relief which was nullification of election.

He also said that the claim of majority of lawful votes pleaded by the petitioners could not avail them since their other claim was that the election was invalid.

He also argued that the number of polling unit agents called as witnesses represented an insignificant or even negligible per cent of the number of polling units in Edo.

Another ground that INEC prayed the tribunal to dismiss the petition was that all the polling unit agents called as witnesses signed the result sheets and they could not distinguish between what they heard and what they saw.

“This is a clear indication that the election was conducted in compliance with the Electoral Act, 2022.

“The results were duly collated at all levels of collation.

“The petitioners have not pleaded any alternative results on the basis of which they can be declared as winners.

“The case of the petitioners is based on analysis undertaken by hired consultants,” he said.

He further held that the documents upon which the petitioners relied were all dumped on the tribunal and could not be used in their favour.

He therefore prayed the tribunal to dismiss the petition in its entirety as it had no merit.

On his part, counsel to Governor Monday Okpebholo, Mr Onyechi Ikpeazu, SAN told the tribunal to dismiss the petition on the grounds that it had become an academic exercise.

He said that in the course of their research, they carefully extracted the polling units which the petitioners tendered documents on and compared them to the ones they presented and even at that, his client was well ahead of the petitioners in the polls.

On the contentious Form EC25b where the petitioners claimed the serial numbers of sensitive materials must be given, Ikpeazu said that all that was required for the form was quantity of electoral materials received and quantity returned.

He added that a pronouncement of the Supreme Court said that one could not prove over voting without the Bimodal Verification Authentication System (BVAs) Machines but that none of the machines was opened to allow the tribunal look at the content.

According to him, the petitioners by not tendering the right documents, failed to prove over voting on the whole.

Speaking on behalf of the All Progressives Congress, (APC) Mr Emmanuel Ukala argued that it was clear that the case of the petitioners was based virtually and entirely on non-compliance.

“By the nature of the case they pleaded, the Supreme Court has over the years laid down that they need to prove this by polling unit to polling unit, ward to ward and local government by local government.”

He, however, held that rather than prove this, the petitioners dumped documents on the court.

Arguing the case of the petitioners, Mr Ken Mozia, SAN, said that with 4519 polling units in Edo, the complaint in the petition was concerning 765 of them.

According to him, it is law that successful prosecution of election petition is not about the percentage of the total polling units in the state but the effect of the successive establishment of the complaint.

He further argued that the petition must be considered whollistically and not in parts.

“So the submission of isolating grounds and labeling them alone as academic is not well founded,” he said.

On the issue of not presenting the tribunal with an alternative result, the senior lawyer said that it was on record that all the results before the tribunal were tendered by his client.

On why the petitioners called only five polling unit agents, he said that the grouse of his client was with what happened at the collation centres and not at the polling units so they didn’t need more than five agents to testify.

“We concede that elections took place at the polling units but how 25 votes metamorphosed to 525 votes at the collation center is what we are quarrelling with,” he said.

Speaking on the claim that they dumped documents on the tribunal, Moze said that all the documents they tendered were duly certified by INEC and were tendered without objection from the commission, the makers of the document.

He also held that the tribunal had requisite jurisdiction to hear the petition because their allegations were not pre-election matters.

Law & Crime

Minna Court adjourns ruling on suit by an APC Aspirant seeking amendment to his Name challenging party’s primary declaring Prof Yakubu Auna as candidate

Published

on

By

By Uthman Baba-Naseer,Minna

The Federal High Court sitting in Minna, Niger State, has adjourned ruling till 16 July for Application filed by an APC aspirant Shehu Samaila Auna seeking for amendment of his name in the matter challenging the APC Primary election which declared Professor Yakubu Mohammed Auna as APC candidate for Magama/Rijau Federal Constituency in the forthcoming elections.

The case, filed by Alhaji Shehu Samaila Auna, is seeking for the cancellation of the APC primary election, alleging that no valid primary was conducted to produce the party’s candidate for the constituency ahead of the 2027 general elections.

Joined as defendants in the suit which is marked FHC/MN/CS/54/2026, are the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Professor Yakubu Mohammed Auna, Shehu Saleh Slow, Safiyanu Yahaya, Emma Alamu, and Sani Doma.

The plaintiff is asking the court to determine whether the APC complied with the provisions of Sections 84, 86 and 87 of the Electoral Act, 2022, in nominating its candidate for the Magama/Rijau Federal Constituency.

He is also seeking a declaration that the party’s candidate was not validly nominated because, according to him, the APC did not conduct a primary election as required by law.

The plaintiff further prayed the court to declare the nomination null and void, arguing that it was carried out in violation of the Electoral Act.

However, at the resumed sitting on Thursday the plaintiff counsel Mohammed Danjuma Abubakar Esq ,had moved an Application to file a motion of amendment of name of the plaintiff as presented in the suit which was heavily objected by the defence counsels.

In his argument the defence counsel Philip Adah Esq vehemently objected to the application on the ground that the amendment of the name of plaintiff at this point is overreach “and I prayed the court to throw out the application as it has no any basis for now”

They argued that the motion is overreaching and did not specify reasons for changing the name of the plaintiff which he originally deposed to.

After listening to the arguments of both parties the presiding judge, Justice Mohammed Aminu Dan-Ige, adjourned the matter to July 16, 2026 for ruling.

Fielding Questions from Journalists shortly after the Court seating, the counsel to the first defendants Philip Adah Esq, argued that the application for the amendment of the names as moved by the counsel to the plaintiff, has no any place inlaw.

Arguing further the counsel had earlier filed an application to amend a name of the plaintiff from the name earlier filed before the court,” then we are now saying that no. He cannot do that because the application is over reach and we are asking the court to as a matter of law,to throw out the application

“ We are hoping that the court under His Lordship will look into our own prayer as contained in our own application to do the needful in our favour or against us as he may deem it fit that is just our prayer before the court” he told Journalists.

However when contacted for his response,the counsel to the plaintiff Mohammed Danjuma Abubakar Esq, declined comment saying,” is not ripe for me to grant any press interview for now. I will speak to the press at the appropriate time. For now I don’t have anything to tell you guys because the hearing has not even commence” he stated.

Continue Reading

Law & Crime

Gov Okpebholo Seeks Traditional Rulers’ Collaboration to Tackle Insecurity

Published

on

By

Senator Monday Okpebholo of Edo state

By Our Edo Correspondent

In a bid to flushout crimes in fhe state,Edo State Governor, Senator Monday Okpebholo is seeking stronger collaboration with traditional rulers across Edo State’s 18 local government areas to tackle insecurity and other criminal activities.

Addressing traditional rulers from Edo Central and Edo North Senatorial Districts on a courtesy visit to Government House in Benin City on Thursday, Governor Okpebholo said traditional rulers remain critical stakeholders in the fight against crime because of their close relationship with their communities.

“There are so many security challenges, and the best people to help me fight insecurity are the traditional rulers. You know your communities because you know those who live there and those coming into the area,” he said.

The governor noted that several recent kidnapping cases involved local collaborators who were familiar with the movement and financial status of residents.

“Our people know those who are wealthy and those who are not. They know the movement of people within the community. If we must stop insecurity in Edo State, we must work together to achieve this purpose,” he said.

He urged traditional rulers not to encourage or shield criminal elements, stressing that young people should be discouraged from engaging in crime.

“Let nobody encourage crime. Our children should not be involved. They should understand that crime is dangerous. The President is not happy about the security situation in the country, and I am not happy as well,” he added.

The governor also appealed to the royal fathers to mobilise support for President Bola Tinubu ahead of the next presidential election, expressing confidence that Edo State could deliver substantial votes for the President.

Responding on behalf of the visiting monarchs, the Ojuromi of Uromi, HRM Anslem Edenojie II, passed a vote of confidence in the governor, describing his development efforts across the state as commendable.

The monarch assured Governor Okpebholo of the continued support and cooperation of traditional rulers in promoting peace, security and development across Edo State.

Continue Reading

Law & Crime

Tinubu Moves to Overhaul Criminal Justice, Seeks Senate Approval to Replace ACJA

Published

on

By

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu

By George Mgbeleke

President Bola Tinubu on Thursday asked the Senate to approve the repeal of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA) 2015 and replace it with a new legal framework designed to tackle delays in criminal trials, strengthen justice sector institutions and modernise Nigeria’s criminal justice system.

The executive bill was conveyed in a letter addressed to Senate President Godswill Akpabio and read during Thursday’s plenary.

In his communication on the criminal justice reform, Tinubu said the proposed Administration of Criminal Justice Bill, 2026, would repeal and replace the existing ACJA 2015 to address persistent legal, procedural and institutional shortcomings that have undermined effective justice delivery.

He explained that the proposed legislation would improve the administration of criminal justice in the Federal Capital Territory and other federal courts, while strengthening the Administration of Criminal Justice Monitoring Council to ensure effective implementation of the law.

According to the President, the new legal framework is intended to promote efficient management of criminal justice institutions, accelerate the dispensation of justice, strengthen the protection of society from crime and safeguard the constitutional rights of suspects, defendants, victims and witnesses.

Tinubu said the bill would also ensure full compliance by courts, law enforcement agencies and other institutions involved in criminal justice administration.

He identified chronic delays in criminal investigations and prosecutions, poor case-file management, inadequate deployment of technology in criminal proceedings, weak coordination among justice sector agencies, ineffective case management systems and poor monitoring of compliance with the existing law as major challenges necessitating the repeal of the 2015 Act.

The President noted that the draft legislation was prepared by experienced law officers with expertise in criminal law, criminal procedure and legislative drafting, adding that it incorporated recent judicial pronouncements, technological innovations and international best practices.

He added that the proposed law would strengthen the Administration of Criminal Justice Monitoring Council through enhanced monitoring and evaluation mechanisms to ensure effective implementation by relevant institutions.

Following the presentation of the communication, the Senate referred the bill to its Committee on Rules and Business with a directive to report back within four weeks.

Continue Reading

Latest

Politics2 hours ago

Kidnapped Oyo Pupils, Teachers Regain Freedom After 56 Days in Captivity,NAWOJ commends FG, Oyo Govt

By Our Oyo Corredpondent The long abducted pupils and teachers from three schools in Oriire Local Government Area of Oyo...

Politics15 hours ago

HURIWA Applauds Evacuation of Nigerians from South Africa, – Demands Compensation for Victims, -Urges Diplomatic Sanctions Over Repeated Xenophobic Attacks

By George Mgbeleke The Human Rights Writers Association of Nigeria (HURIWA) commends the Federal Government of Nigeria and Air Peace...

Politics16 hours ago

Stop voting by tribe, religion, Yoruba activist backs Atiku for 2027

By Our Correspondent South-West governance activist, Dr. Jackson Lekan Ojo, has urged Nigerians to jettison ethnic and religious sentiments and...

Politics16 hours ago

Respect S/Court Judgement-SDP Urges Ex-Nat.Chairman, Shehu Gabam

By George Mgbeleke The Social Democratic Party (SDP) has advised its expelled former National Chairman, to respect the judgement of...

Business & Economy18 hours ago

Rivers 2026 Budget Gov. Fubara presents N1.8tri. ……Reaffirms Commitment to Prudent Management of Resources

By George Mgbeleke Governor of Rivers State, His Excellency, Sir Siminalayi Fubara on Friday, presented the 2026 Budget estimates of...

Business & Economy18 hours ago

Grow Blue Economy in the Niger Delta.” ~ Bayelsa Monarch Tells FG, State Govts

By David Owei,Bayelsa The Acting Amayanabo of Okpoama Kingdom in Brass Council Area, High Chief Nathan Egba-Dienegha has called on...

Law & Crime19 hours ago

Minna Court adjourns ruling on suit by an APC Aspirant seeking amendment to his Name challenging party’s primary declaring Prof Yakubu Auna as candidate

By Uthman Baba-Naseer,Minna The Federal High Court sitting in Minna, Niger State, has adjourned ruling till 16 July for Application...

Business & Economy1 day ago

Market Demolitions, Poor Infrastructure Threaten Traders’ Survival” — Lagos Market Leader Cry out

By Our Lagos Correspondent Disturbed incessant demolition of markets in Lagos state, President of Ndigboamaka Progressive Market Association, Comrade Chinedu...

General News1 day ago

Tinubu Unveils Remodeled Abuja City Gate, Hails It As “Symbol of Unity” for FCT’s 50th Anniversary

By Our Correspondent President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has commissioned the newly remodeled Abuja City Gate, describing the landmark as a...

Law & Crime1 day ago

Gov Okpebholo Seeks Traditional Rulers’ Collaboration to Tackle Insecurity

By Our Edo Correspondent In a bid to flushout crimes in fhe state,Edo State Governor, Senator Monday Okpebholo is seeking...

Trending